As I prepare for fall semester, I know that a significant part of my beginning and intermediate Spanish courses will take place online. One of my top priorities is to choose web applications that foster communication in the target language (TL) and are accessible to the diverse range of learners in my classes. After recently reading Disability and World Language Learning: Inclusive Teaching for Diverse Learners (2019) by Sally Scott and Wade Edwards, I have been reflecting on the instructional choices I make to best meet the needs of all my students.
One step I am taking this summer is to evaluate some of the web applications I use in terms of their capacity to help create an inclusive learning environment. The principles of Universal Design for Instruction (UDI) provide a helpful framework for such a task. The nine principles include: equitable use, flexibility in use, simple and intuitive, perceptible information, tolerance for error, low physical effort, size and space for approach and use, a community of learners, and instructional climate (Scott, Shaw & McGuire, 2001).
In this post, I'll do a bit of reflection regarding Flipgrid, an interactive video discussion board that includes common features in social media apps that students might already use. For example, students can add stickers, emojis, selfies, and filters to their Fligrid videos. This app has a very fun vibe, and I love seeing and hearing from my students, especially during remote instruction.
Here I will discuss how the features of Flipgrid address some of the principles of UDI and how teachers can leverage this app successfully to create a more inclusive world language classroom.
Equitable Use: Do all students have access to materials and instruction? Is this application useful for people with diverse abilities?
- Students can access Flipgrid on a variety of devices--computer, laptop, or smart phone. It's also completely FREE to use!
- Students who might be more reluctant to share in a face-to-face classroom have the opportunity to participate on a more even playing field.
- Students with concerns about privacy or safety have options to avoid recording their face on the camera. There is a white board feature where they can draw or upload an image, they can cover their face with an emoji sticker, or they can choose the pixel filter that obscures their face. I like that these options are still fun, and students are not stigmatized for their choice. Teachers can also adjust the settings using "video moderation" to hide student responses.
Whiteboard feature
Emoji feature
Pixelated feature
Flexibility in Use: Do students have choice in how they use it according to their preferences and abilities? Are there a variety of ways to engage using this tool?
- Teachers can create variety and novelty in the tasks they design. A few tasks I have tried include guessing games for circumlocution, expressing reactions about a film students watched in Spanish, and sharing ideas for how to care for the environment. I also loved Kara Jacob's idea to use Flipgrid for a dictation activity with the video moderation feature enabled. This allows Flipgrid to also be a source of comprehensible input.
- Students have choice regarding the features of their video--whether they want to write text, use a filter, include stickers or drawings, use the white board feature, or upload an image.
- When listening to videos, students can slow down the pace. I have used a few Flipgrid videos of native speakers as listening tasks in my classroom, and this was a helpful feature.
- Students can upload videos recorded outside of the Flipgrid application. For example, they can upload a video they created with a screen casting program or with Adobe Spark!
Simple and Intuitive: Can students use the application in a "straightforward and predictable" way (Scott, Shaw & McGuire, 2001)?
- In the time that I have been using Flipgrid, I have gotten very few (if any that I can recall) emails or questions from students with reports of challenges or difficulties using the application.
- Icons for navigating the application are clear and seem intuitive. When you record a video and the different options display (filter, white board, etc.), each one has an image and if you hover over the icon with your mouse, it displays text to further explain.
Perceptible Information: Does the app allow students to access necessary information "regardless of ambient conditions or the student's sensory abilities" (Scott, Shaw & McGuire, 2001)?
- Flipgrid has an Immersive Reader feature that will read text in the prompt to students. It will automatically detect the language, so it can read the text to students with appropriate pronunciation, intonation, etc.
- Students can add their own closed captioning using the text feature or by adding a URL that links to a Google doc with their text.
Immersive Reader feature
Tolerance for Error: Is there adequate support and structure to accommodate students' different skill levels and background knowledge? Do app features help students avoid "unintended actions" (What is Universal Design?: The 7 Principles)?
- There are clear prompts throughout the app to confirm or cancel possible unintended actions, such as deleting or uploading their video.
- Teachers can easily provide feedback to students, either through text or video.
- I prefer to use Flipgrid videos as a low-stakes assignment in terms of grades, which allows students to take risks with the language without fear of negative impact on their grade.
- The teacher may provide students with sentence starters or helpful phrases to support a variety of abilities in the TL.
A Community of Learners: Does this app provide a way for students to connect with one another and with their teacher?
- Teachers can create prompts that encourage students to interact with one another. For example, the prompt might be a guessing game, require students to identify something they have in common, or respond to a question posed by their peers.
- It's important that the teacher structures the assignment so that all students have the same opportunity to respond and interact; you want to avoid some students getting dozens of responses while other students may not get any. I love that the course I am taking this summer groups students, and we are responsible for responding to those in our group, thus ensuring equal interaction.
- Teacher interaction with students is also essential on Flipgrid. In their article "How to Establish a Strong Community in an Online Course," Maeda and Rosen (2020) explain that this interaction "may be as simple as liking a video that your students post, response to a student video, or it might be holding up one of your students’ examples as a model for others." By also posting a video as a model for students, they will get to know more about you as an instructor.
Instructional Climate: Does this app contribute to creating a "welcoming and inclusive" classroom dynamic (Scott, Shaw & McGuire, 2001)?
- The app has many elements that feel fun and allow students and teachers to use humor (Maeda & Rosen, 2020).
- In designing tasks appropriate for their proficiency level, teachers can create an inclusive space where all students can feel successful.
By evaluating Flipgrid's features with the principles of UDI, I can affirm the value of this app for creating a more inclusive world language classroom. This coming semester, I would like to continue using it and find ways I can expand upon how I have previously used it.
Have you used Flipgrid? What features do you find especially helpful for creating an inclusive classroom? How might you adapt your future use of this app?
Sources
- Darby, A. (n.d.) "Understanding Universal Design in the Classroom" [Web page].
- Jacobs, K. (2019). Easy and adaptable sub plans. [Blog]. Retrieved from http://www.ceauthres.com/2019/10/easy-and-adaptable-sub-plans.html.
- Maeda, M. & Rosen, L. (2020, June 22). "How to Establish a Strong Community in an Online Course." The FLTMAG.
- Scott, S., McGuire, J., & Shaw, S. (2001). Principles of Universal Design for Instruction. Center on Postsecondary Education and Disability, University of Connecticut.
- Scott, S. & Edwards, W. (2019). Disability and World Language Learning: Inclusive Teaching for Diverse Learners. London: Rowman & Littlefield.
- What is Universal Design?: The 7 Principles [Web page].



Christa,
ReplyDeleteThanks for your research. I wasn't aware of the UDI principles and I find so useful that there is a way to assess what we use for instruction not just based on our personal preferences but with rigorous criteria and with the benefit of students in mind.
I actually think there should be some independent evaluation agency reporting on the suitability of digital learning tools, something like the FDA but for education. I have the impression that there is a very liberal approach to the use and implementation of online tools and we should demand some regulation to ensure that tools are beneficial for students and teachers, not just for the companies that design them.
I love the nine principles and you actually inspired me to perform a similar discussion with other tools I'm using.
I completely agree with you, Alexis, about the need for better "regulation" of tools. Some institutions have specialists, but it can take a long time to get their approval. Some companies provide statements about accessibility, but I don't think anyone really checks. For example, when I first wanted to use Extempore, the specialist on campus said it didn't meet accessibility standards. The company was very receptive to feedback, and they made all the changes requested, which I really appreciate. But I was a bit surprised that companies can just put their site together and not have to abide by ADA requirements.
DeleteChrista,
ReplyDeleteHard to choose where to start when the way you have formatted this is so thoughtful, and applicable to everything we do as educators.
Regarding the classroom climate, I believe that it feels welcoming, fun, and inclusive.
Is it intuitive? I agree that I have not yet had a student, with all of the new platforms that we implemented, inquire about difficulties with the platform. In fact, the only "errors" I ever experienced were due to me having 5 classes, and someone using a prompt from a different class. As long as their email address is a district address, they can enter any "class" if they have access to the "topic" code. Also, at the beginning of the pandemic and throughout, I worked closely with students with Individualized Education Plans and FlipGrid was never touched upon except when we talked about the value participating.
Participation. That brings me to the class community and the article that you shared. The idea of social, teaching, and cognitive presences is fascinating and feels like what is at the core of reacting to our communities given the global situation. This past week I listened to public comments on whether or not our district should return to full time face-to-face. If we were to have to do things remotely or as a hybrid (and even face-to-face), FlipGrid is a great platform. The community is very worried about the breakdown of our educational experiences. But, if we are not completely face-to-face, lessons done carefully have the possibility of creating and helping maintain a positive educational experience. Students share and are "seen"; teachers/instructors/professors can support and respond to their students easily... synchronously (I've done Zooms where my students meet there, log off and do a FlipGrid activity, and then return to Zoom.) and asynchronously. I used FlipGrid almost completely asynchronously. When listening to community members saying it was important to return completely face-to-face it reminded me that FlipGrid, without being physically face-to-face, allows us to be "present".
I liked the dictation activities described in the link. I can imagine doing short stories, song lyrics, and poems using FlipGrid.
Regarding in the future, in my classroom normally I have students in groups of 4 or 5. I agree with your thoughts about this class that we are taking together: chunking the work by grouping the students. It's much easier to start out small. Whether face-to-face or not, FlipGrid could be a great vehicle for students to introduce themselves to us, and each other. But, to keep it private within just the group (even though they could share the information), each group could have it's own "class"... a little more cumbersome if you have 120 students.
Alexis commented on something about which I think each time I use a new platform. It made me think of the "legal stuff" on the ACTFL SIG that reminds users to be careful with this "public" forum, and that reminds potential salespeople what the avenues are for those types of posts.
Wonderful post!
What a great post, Christa!
ReplyDeleteThe only thing I'll add is (which is probably implied in some of the questions you listed): Does the tool support other languages? For example, the immersive reader feature works only with English instructions, I believe (i.e., the machine pronounces every word as an English word). As for captions, I wish the automatic captioning worked for languages other than English... but in that case, it might defeat the purpose of the dictation! Compared to other tools out there, Flipgrid fares much better in this respect, but it's one more thing to consider.
Privacy is always a concern online, even if you set your grids as private. Nothing is really "free" or private! I like what you mention regarding giving students choices in terms of how/what to record.
If you're interested in tool evaluations, commonsense.org is a good site to explore; here's Flipgrid's eval regarding privacy: https://privacy.commonsense.org/evaluation/Flipgrid
Thanks for your feedback, Florencia! I did a bit more experimenting with the immersive reader feature, and I was glad to discover that it does work with Spanish! It seemed to work without my changing the settings, so I wonder if it automatically detects the language? Also, Microsoft has a page called "Languages and products supported by Immersive Reader" where you can choose the language and then see what products it is available with, and Flipgrid is one of the product options. Another option for accessible instructions / prompts could also be through "Topic Attachments" where the instructor can include a link to a document in OneNote, Google docs (to be used with a screen reader), etc.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the recommendation of commonsense.org! That will be a really helpful site for considering the safety and privacy features of a variety of tools. I understand that some K-12 schools do not permit their teachers to use Flipgrid, which I am sure is most likely related to these concerns.